BOOKKEEPING & BUSINESS CLARITY · 3 MIN READ
Why Does My Profit and Loss Change When I Switch Between Cash and Accrual?
By Hevia & Hevia CPA Firm · Published
Reviewed by Alexander Hevia, CPA, J.D., LL.M. (Taxation) —
Your profit-and-loss statement can change when you switch between cash and accrual because the two reporting bases recognize income and expenses at different times. A different result does not automatically mean one report is incorrect.
The important questions are which basis you are viewing, whether the records support that report, and what you intend to use it for.
What is the basic difference?
Under cash-basis reporting, income generally follows receipt of payment and expenses generally follow payment.
Under accrual-basis reporting, income generally follows when it is earned, while expenses are generally recognized when incurred, subject to applicable accounting rules.
For tax purposes, additional requirements and exceptions apply, including constructive receipt, capitalization, prepayments, and rules governing when an expense is incurred. IRS Publication 538
How can the same transaction appear in different periods?
Consider a simplified example involving completed services, correctly recorded transactions, and no special exceptions:
| Transaction | Cash-basis illustration | Accrual-basis illustration |
|---|---|---|
| Your business completes a $5,000 job in December, but payment is not received or available until January. | Revenue generally appears in January. | Revenue generally appears in December. |
| Your business incurs an $800 charge for services provided in December and pays it in January. | The expense generally appears in January. | The expense generally appears in December. |
This illustrates reporting timing. It is not a determination of the proper tax treatment for a particular transaction.
Which report should I use?
The appropriate report depends on the question.
Accrual reporting can help connect activity with the period in which it occurred. Cash-basis reporting can help explain receipts and payments included under that reporting basis.
Neither report should be read in isolation. A cash-basis profit-and-loss statement still does not explain every bank movement: loan principal, owner distributions, and certain asset purchases can affect cash differently from profit.
For more context, read My Business Shows a Profit—So Why Is There No Cash?.
Does switching the report change my tax accounting method?
No. Changing a report setting does not, by itself, change the accounting method used on your tax return.
Changing an established tax accounting method generally requires IRS consent. Form 3115 and an applicable consent procedure may be required. Discuss a proposed change with your tax professional before treating a software setting as permission to report differently. IRS information about Form 3115
What should I check if the difference seems unreasonable?
Confirm the date range, accounting basis, and any report filters. Review whether invoices, payments, expenses, and other transactions were entered consistently.
Changing the reporting basis does not repair missing activity, duplicate entries, or incorrect classifications. The underlying records must still be reliable.
Hevia & Hevia CPA Firm helps business owners understand their bookkeeping and financial reports. Where separately engaged, we coordinate those records with tax planning and advisory.
Our Miami-based team serves South Florida and works remotely throughout Florida. Contact our firm to discuss your reporting needs.
FURTHER READING